The Best Restaurants in Lake Geneva & Surrounding Areas – 2025 Update

by Kim & Joel Reyenga

The Best Restaurants in Lake Geneva & Surrounding Areas – 2025 Update

Lake Geneva has long been known for its stunning lakefront views, charming downtown, and vibrant dining scene. Whether you are a local, a visitor, or a future homeowner, knowing where to find the best restaurants can elevate your experience. From fine dining to casual lakefront eats, steakhouses to family-friendly spots, there’s something for everyone.

As local real estate experts with eXp Realty, Kim & Joel Reyenga not only help clients find their dream homes but also introduce them to the best that Lake Geneva has to offer—including its incredible restaurants. Here’s our updated 2025 guide to the top restaurants in Lake Geneva and surrounding areas, perfect for any occasion.

Best Fine Dining Restaurants in Lake Geneva

1. 240° West (Lake Geneva)

Location: The Abbey Resort, Fontana
Best For: Special occasions, lakefront fine dining

Located inside The Abbey Resort, 240° West offers an elegant dining experience with panoramic lake views. The menu focuses on seasonal ingredients and elevated Midwest cuisine, with highlights like prime steaks, seafood, and gourmet pasta dishes. Pair your meal with a curated wine selection and enjoy the cozy ambiance.

2. Geneva ChopHouse (Lake Geneva)

Location: Grand Geneva Resort
Best For: Steak lovers, upscale dining

If you’re looking for the best steakhouse in Lake Geneva, Geneva ChopHouse is a top choice. Known for its dry-aged steaks, fresh seafood, and premium cocktails, this fine dining spot is perfect for romantic dinners and celebratory occasions. The outdoor patio seating in the warmer months makes it even more appealing.

3. Ristorante Brissago (Lake Geneva)

Location: Grand Geneva Resort
Best For: Authentic Italian cuisine

Ristorante Brissago brings a true taste of Italy to Lake Geneva. Their handmade pasta, wood-fired pizzas, and fresh seafood dishes showcase authentic Italian flavors. The restaurant also offers an impressive wine list featuring Italian imports.

Best Casual & Family-Friendly Restaurants

4. Popeye’s on Lake Geneva (Lake Geneva)

Best For: Classic Wisconsin dining with a lake view

A Lake Geneva staple, Popeye’s is famous for its rotisserie meats, Wisconsin fish fry, and lakefront seating. This spot is great for families, large groups, and visitors looking for a casual yet delicious meal with a view of Geneva Lake.

5. Oakfire (Lake Geneva)

Best For: Neapolitan pizza and lake views

If you’re craving authentic Neapolitan-style pizza, Oakfire is the place to go. Their wood-fired pizzas, fresh salads, and Italian appetizers make for a great casual dining experience. The two-story restaurant offers some of the best views of Lake Geneva.

6. Simple Café (Lake Geneva)

Best For: Breakfast, brunch, and farm-to-table dishes

Simple Café is known for its healthy, locally sourced menu and creative breakfast options. Their avocado toast, farm-fresh omelets, and seasonal specials make it a favorite among locals.

7. Lucke’s Cantina (Williams Bay)

Best For: Mexican food and margaritas

Williams Bay’s go-to spot for tacos, burritos, and margaritas, Lucke’s Cantina is a fun, casual restaurant with a relaxed vibe. Their homemade salsa and fresh guacamole are must-tries.

Best Waterfront Restaurants

8. Pier 290 (Williams Bay)

Best For: Waterfront dining with boat access

Located directly on Geneva Lake, Pier 290 is one of the only true waterfront restaurants in the area. They offer seafood, steaks, and cocktails, plus an outdoor fire pit and live music in the summer. Dock your boat right at the restaurant for a true lakefront dining experience.

9. Gordy’s Boat House (Fontana)

Best For: Laid-back lakefront dining

Gordy’s Boat House is a boater’s paradise, serving burgers, sandwiches, and seafood in a relaxed setting. Their rooftop patio offers stunning views of the lake, and it’s a great place to grab a drink after a day on the water.

10. Mars Resort (Lake Como)

Best For: Classic Wisconsin supper club experience

Located on Lake Como, Mars Resort is a legendary supper club known for its Friday fish fry, prime rib, and old-fashioned cocktails. The live piano music and rustic charm make it a must-visit spot.

Hidden Gem Restaurants in Lake Geneva & Surrounding Areas

11. Next Door Pub (Lake Geneva)

Best For: Local favorite for pizza and pub fare

A true Lake Geneva hidden gem, Next Door Pub is a favorite among locals for its hand-tossed pizza, burgers, and craft beers. Their cheese curds are some of the best in the area.

12. Café Calamari (Williams Bay)

Best For: Italian food in an intimate setting

A small, cozy Italian restaurant in Williams Bay, Café Calamari is perfect for a date night or family dinner. Their seafood pasta dishes and homemade desserts are highlights.

13. The Duck Inn Supper Club (Delavan)

Best For: Classic Wisconsin supper club experience

Located just outside of Delavan, The Duck Inn offers a traditional supper club atmosphere with steak, seafood, and classic cocktails. Their brandy old-fashioned is a must-try.

Planning to Move to Lake Geneva? Let Kim & Joel Reyenga Help You Find the Perfect Home

Lake Geneva isn’t just a vacation destination—it’s also a wonderful place to live, work, and invest in real estate. If you are considering buying a home in Lake Geneva, Fontana, Williams Bay, or the surrounding areas, working with local experts can make all the difference.

Kim & Joel Reyenga of eXp Realty have years of experience in the Lake Geneva market and can help you find the perfect home—whether it’s a lakefront property, vacation retreat, or family home.